Naar de inhoud
OneKitly

An Ellipse Has a Simple Area and No Simple Perimeter

Gepubliceerd op 20-10-2026 · 4 min leestijd · Dagelijkse calculators

Lena Hoffmann

Lena Hoffmann — Redacteur wetenschap en onderwijs bij OneKitly

Wiskunde · Natuurkunde

Getoetst aan 2 bronnen

Profiel bekijken →
Kort gezegd

The area of an ellipse is π times the two semi-axes multiplied together, as clean a formula as anyone could want. The perimeter has no such expression: it is an elliptic integral, a quantity that provably cannot be written with the ordinary functions of arithmetic, and every figure you will ever see quoted comes from an approximation or a numerical integration. This calculator returns 25.5270 for semi-axes of 5 and 3, and the exact value differs from it by about one part in two million — good enough that the distinction never matters in practice. The naive guess of π times the sum of the axes gives 25.1327, 1.5 per cent low, and it gets steadily worse as the ellipse stretches.

Advertentie

Semi-axes 5 and 3 give a perimeter of 25.5270, and the exact value differs by one part in two million. The obvious guess, π(a+b), is 1.5 % low — and 15 % low on a long thin ellipse.

The approximation degrades too, just far later

At semi-axes of 5 and 3 the calculator's answer and the exact integral agree to six figures. Stretch the shape to 10 and 1 and the agreement loosens to about eight parts in ten thousand — still far better than anything a tape measure would resolve, and no longer the exactness the displayed digits imply. That is the honest reading of any figure produced by an approximation: it is right to a stated precision that depends on the inputs, not right absolutely. Where an ellipse is close to circular the approximation is essentially perfect; where it is a long thin sliver, quote fewer digits than the screen offers.

Where the problem actually shows up

Anywhere a length has to be cut to fit an oval. The trim around an elliptical mirror, the edging of an oval bed, the belt around two unequal pulleys and the seam of an oval tabletop all need the perimeter and none of them are helped by the area. The historical case is planetary orbits: the distance a planet travels in one circuit is exactly this integral, and the family of functions invented to handle it took its name from the problem. A practical rule when the shape is drawn rather than specified: measure the outline with a flexible tape rather than computing it, because a real oval is rarely a mathematical ellipse in the first place.

Perimeter
How the naive guess fails as the ellipse stretches
Semi-axesPerimeterπ(a+b)Error of the guess
10 and 959.731659.6903−0.07 %
5 and 325.527025.1327−1.54 %
10 and 140.605534.5575−14.97 %

Uitgewerkt met onze eigen calculator

Omtrekcalculator ellips

Gegeven

Halve lange as (a)
3
Halve korte as (b)
2

Resultaat

Omtrek
15,865

Deze cijfers komen uit de calculator hieronder, ze zijn niet met de hand ingetypt — ze worden opnieuw berekend telkens als de tool verandert.

Reken het door met je eigen cijfers →
Advertentie

Veelgestelde vragen

What does it mean that no formula exists?
It is a statement about a specific vocabulary, not an admission of ignorance. The perimeter is perfectly well defined and can be computed to as many digits as anyone wants; what it cannot be is written down using only the familiar operations — roots, powers, logarithms, trigonometric functions and their combinations. Mathematicians proved that no such expression exists, then defined new functions specifically to name the quantity, and those functions are now as computable as a sine. The circle is the exception, not the rule: most curves have lengths that behave like this one, and the circle's tidy 2πr is a piece of good luck rather than the normal state of affairs.
Does setting both axes equal really give a circle?
Yes, and it is the fastest available sanity check on any ellipse formula. Semi-axes of 5 and 5 give a perimeter of 31.4159, which is 2π times 5 to every digit shown, and the area formula collapses to πr² at the same moment. Any approximation worth using reproduces the circle exactly rather than approximately, because the awkward part of the integral vanishes when the two axes match. An expression that got the circle slightly wrong would be telling you it is doing something other than what it claims — which makes this the first test to run on a formula found in a forum post.

Artikelen die je misschien interesseren

Alle gidsen →

Vergelijkbare tools

Bronnen

Een fout in dit artikel gezien?