Cross-Multiply and You Never Need a Decimal Point
Gepubliceerd op 4-11-2026 · 3 min leestijd · Dagelijkse calculators
Lena Hoffmann — Redacteur wetenschap en onderwijs bij OneKitly
Wiskunde · Natuurkunde
Getoetst aan 2 bronnen
To compare two fractions, multiply each numerator by the other denominator and compare the two products. For 7/9 and 8/11 that gives 77 and 72, so 7/9 wins — and the decimals confirm it at 0.7778 against 0.7273. The advantage is exactness: 5/7 against 7/10 gives 50 against 49, a margin of one that decimal comparison would show as 0.714286 against 0.700000, correct here but vulnerable to rounding in tighter cases. Equal products mean equal fractions, which is how the method confirms that 1001/1309 and 13/17 are the same number without reducing either one.
Is 7/9 bigger than 8/11? Multiply 7 by 11 and 8 by 9: 77 against 72, so yes. Two whole-number products settle it exactly, with no rounding anywhere.
Why the bigger denominator loses
With the same numerator, a bigger denominator always means a smaller fraction: 1/8 is less than 1/3 because eight shares of a cake are smaller than three. This reverses the usual instinct that bigger numbers mean more, and it is the single most common source of confusion with fractions among learners of any age. The cross-multiplication method sidesteps the intuition entirely by converting both fractions to a comparison of whole numbers, which is why it works reliably for people who find the underlying idea slippery. The intuition is worth building anyway, since it is the only thing that catches an answer entered the wrong way round.
The fraction that sits between two others
Add the numerators and add the denominators and you get a fraction guaranteed to lie between the two you started with: from 5/7 and 7/10 comes 12/17, which is 0.7059, comfortably between 0.7 and 0.7143. The operation looks like an error — it is exactly the way children are told never to add fractions — and yet it produces something meaningful every time. It is the basis of the sequence of all fractions in lowest terms arranged in order, used historically to find the simplest fraction within a given tolerance of a measurement, which is how gear ratios and calendar approximations were chosen before calculators.
| Pair | Cross products | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 7/9 and 8/11 | 77 and 72 | 7/9 is bigger |
| 5/7 and 7/10 | 50 and 49 | 5/7 is bigger |
| 3/4 and 5/8 | 24 and 20 | 3/4 is bigger |
| 13/17 and 1001/1309 | 17 017 each | Equal |
Uitgewerkt met onze eigen calculator
Calculator breuken vergelijken
Gegeven
- Teller 1
- 6
- Noemer 1
- 8
- Teller 2
- 10
- Noemer 2
- 16
Resultaat
- Breuk 1 (decimaal)
- 0,75
- Breuk 2 (decimaal)
- 0,625
Deze cijfers komen uit de calculator hieronder, ze zijn niet met de hand ingetypt — ze worden opnieuw berekend telkens als de tool verandert.
Reken het door met je eigen cijfers →Veelgestelde vragen
- Does cross-multiplication work with negative fractions?
- Only if both denominators are positive, and that condition is easy to forget. Multiplying an inequality by a negative number reverses it, so a negative denominator flips the comparison and the method silently returns the wrong answer. The fix is to move any minus sign to the numerator first — write −3/4 rather than 3/−4 — after which the products can be compared normally. Software that implements the method usually normalises signs before doing anything else, and code that omits that step tends to work in testing and fail on the first user who types a minus in the wrong place.
- Is comparing decimals ever better?
- For sorting a long list, yes. Cross-multiplication compares two fractions at a time and gives no ordering key, so sorting a hundred of them means a hundred-fold multiplication of pairwise comparisons; converting each to a decimal once and sorting those is far cheaper. The trade is exactness against speed, and the safe compromise is to sort on decimals and then verify any pair that came out close using the exact method. Where the fractions represent money or measured quantities and the differences are meaningful, the verification step is not optional.
Artikelen die je misschien interesseren
Alle gidsen →Vergelijkbare tools
Bronnen
Een fout in dit artikel gezien?