The Banana Unit Explains a Number It Cannot Measure
Gepubliceerd op 23-10-2026 · 3 min leestijd · Gezondheidscalculators
Sofia Nunes — Redacteur gezondheid en welzijn bij OneKitly
Voeding · Vochtinname
Getoetst aan 2 bronnen
A banana contains potassium, a small fraction of which is naturally radioactive, and eating one is conventionally taken as about 0.1 microsieverts of dose. Dividing by that gives the banana equivalent dose: 100 microsieverts is 1,000 bananas, a millisievert is 10,000, and twenty millisieverts is 200,000. As a way of showing that a small number is small, it works — most people have no feel for a microsievert and a great deal of feel for a banana. As arithmetic it breaks immediately, because the body holds potassium at a regulated level and excretes the excess: eating a second banana does not leave you carrying twice the potassium, so the doses genuinely do not add.
100 microsieverts is a thousand bananas, and a millisievert is ten thousand. The comparison makes the scale intuitive and the arithmetic misleading, because eating bananas does not accumulate dose.
The unit was invented to defuse a number, not to compute with it
Its whole purpose is comparison against something familiar and obviously harmless, and on that ground it is a good communication device: a figure that sounds alarming in an unfamiliar unit becomes a fruit bowl. The failure comes when the comparison is pushed past its job — when the bananas are added up, projected over a year, or used to argue that a source is safe because its output equals so many pieces of fruit. The right reading is qualitative and one-directional: it can tell you a number is small, and it cannot tell you what any particular number means for a person.
A sievert already carries an interpretation
The sievert is not a measure of energy deposited — that is the gray — but of energy weighted for how damaging the radiation type is and how sensitive the tissue receiving it is. Two exposures of the same number of sieverts to different tissues from different sources are held to carry comparable risk, and that comparability is the entire point of the unit and the reason the weighting factors exist. Converting a sievert figure into bananas throws away everything the weighting encoded, leaving a count of fruit that no longer distinguishes a whole-body exposure from a dental image.
| Dose | In microsieverts | Bananas |
|---|---|---|
| One banana | 0.1 | 1 |
| 0.1 mSv | 100 | 1,000 |
| 1 mSv | 1,000 | 10,000 |
| 20 mSv | 20,000 | 200,000 |
Uitgewerkt met onze eigen calculator
Bananenstraling-calculator (equivalente dosis)
Gegeven
- Stralingsdosis
- 100
- Dosiseenheid
- microsievert (µSv)
Resultaat
- Bananenequivalentdoses (BED)
- 1.000 bananas
- Dosis
- 100 µSv
- Dosis
- 0,1 mSv
- Dosis
- 10 mrem
Deze cijfers komen uit de calculator hieronder, ze zijn niet met de hand ingetypt — ze worden opnieuw berekend telkens als de tool verandert.
Reken het door met je eigen cijfers →Veelgestelde vragen
- Where does the 0.1 microsievert per banana come from?
- From the potassium content of a typical banana and the known fraction of potassium that is the radioactive isotope, worked through to a dose. Every step carries a range: bananas vary in size and ripeness, the estimate depends on assumptions about how the dose is spread over time, and different sources round it differently. The figure is best read as an order of magnitude rather than a constant, and the same is true of the many other everyday comparisons built the same way — a transatlantic flight, a brick house, a night at altitude.
- Is there a better everyday comparison?
- Background radiation is the usual one and it is better on every count that matters. Everyone receives a dose from the ground, the air and space simply by existing, the annual figure is published for most regions, and unlike bananas it genuinely accumulates over time — so expressing a dose as a fraction of a year of background is both intuitive and arithmetically sound. It also invites the right follow-up question, which is how much the local background actually is, since it varies several-fold with geology and altitude.
Artikelen die je misschien interesseren
Alle gidsen →Vergelijkbare tools
This article explains a rhetorical unit, not a safety threshold. Radiation exposure limits are set by national and international bodies and depend on the source, the tissue and whether the exposure is occupational or public; nothing here is a limit, a diagnosis, or a reason to accept or refuse a medical procedure. If a dose figure on a scan request or a workplace badge concerns you, ask the clinician or radiation protection officer who issued it.
Bronnen
Een fout in dit artikel gezien?