The Midwife Outpulls Mars, But Not the Moon
Gepubliceerd op 28-10-2026 · 3 min leestijd · Dagelijkse calculators
Lena Hoffmann — Redacteur wetenschap en onderwijs bij OneKitly
Wiskunde · Natuurkunde
Getoetst aan 2 bronnen
Gravitational attraction falls off as the square of the distance, and that is why a nearby small mass can beat a distant enormous one. Run the numbers: a 100 kg attendant standing 0.5 m from a 70 kg patient exerts 1.87 microNewtons, while Mars — 640 000 million million million kilograms of it — exerts 0.99 microNewtons from 55 million km at its closest approach. The attendant wins, by a factor of 1.9. But the Moon is close, and it exerts 2 324 microNewtons on the same person: 1 244 times the attendant. The debunking works against Mars and fails against the Moon, which is a useful reminder to check which body you are actually comparing.
A 100 kg person half a metre away pulls on a newborn with 1.9 μN; Mars at its closest manages 0.99 μN. The Moon, however, manages 2 300 μN.
Why the Earth's pull is 370 million times bigger
The Earth is both enormous and, in the sense that matters, extremely close: its whole mass acts as though concentrated at the centre, 6 371 km away, and that distance is small compared to the Moon's. Multiply the mass ratio by the inverse square of the distance ratio and you get the 687 N you feel as weight — 300 000 times the Moon's pull on you, and roughly 370 million times a nearby person's. Note also that computing the Earth's pull from the universal law gives 687.4 N while the familiar mass-times-9.81 shortcut gives 686.7 N. The 0.1 % gap is not an error in either method; it is the rotation of the planet and its slightly flattened shape, folded into the value of 9.81 that we treat as constant.
Being bigger than Mars is not being big
Both figures in the famous comparison are around a microNewton, which is the weight of a tenth of a milligram — a fragment of a grain of sand. Neither one moves anything. The comparison is rhetorically effective and physically empty, and it is worth noticing that the Moon's pull, a thousand times larger, is also far too weak to do anything to a body: the Moon raises tides in oceans because the difference in its pull across thousands of kilometres accumulates over a whole basin, not because the pull on any one object is meaningful. A person contains no basin. Scale arguments have to be finished, not started.
| Source | Distance | Force |
|---|---|---|
| Earth | 6 371 km (surface) | 687 N |
| Moon | 384 400 km | 2 324 μN |
| Person, 100 kg | 0.5 m | 1.87 μN |
| Mars, closest | 55 million km | 0.99 μN |
| Two people, 70 kg each | 1 m | 0.33 μN |
Uitgewerkt met onze eigen calculator
Calculator zwaartekracht
Gegeven
- Massa 1 (kg)
- 1.000
- Massa 2 (kg)
- 1.000
- Afstand (m)
- 10
Resultaat
- Zwaartekracht (N)
- 0
Deze cijfers komen uit de calculator hieronder, ze zijn niet met de hand ingetypt — ze worden opnieuw berekend telkens als de tool verandert.
Reken het door met je eigen cijfers →Veelgestelde vragen
- Why is Mars's distance given as a range?
- Because it varies by a factor of seven over the two planets' orbits. At the most favourable oppositions Mars comes within about 55 million km; at conjunction, on the far side of the Sun, it is over 400 million km away. The pull therefore varies by a factor of nearly fifty between those extremes, and the figure quoted here is the most generous one available to Mars. Using an average distance would make the comparison even more lopsided, which is why the strongest case still loses to a person standing nearby.
- Can two ordinary objects be seen to attract each other?
- Yes, but it took a purpose-built instrument and a quiet cellar. Cavendish measured the attraction between lead spheres in 1798 using a torsion balance — a rod hung from a fine wire, so that a force of a fraction of a microNewton produces a visible twist. He isolated the apparatus from draughts and observed it through a telescope from another room, because his own body heat was enough to ruin the reading. That experiment is what supplies the constant every gravitational calculation still uses, and it remains the least precisely known of the fundamental constants.
Artikelen die je misschien interesseren
Alle gidsen →Vergelijkbare tools
Bronnen
Een fout in dit artikel gezien?