Naar de inhoud
OneKitly

Two Accepted Models, Two Points Apart on the Same Company

Gepubliceerd op 21-9-2026 · 3 min leestijd · Financiële calculators

Camille Laurent

Camille Laurent — Financieel redacteur bij OneKitly

Belastingen · Persoonlijke financiën

Getoetst aan 2 bronnen

Profiel bekijken →
Kort gezegd

Take a risk-free rate of 3 %, a beta of 1.2, an expected market return of 8 %, a dividend of 2 on a price of 50 and dividend growth of 3 %. CAPM says 3 + 1.2 × (8 − 3) = 9 %. The dividend growth model says 2 ÷ 50 + 3 % = 7 %. Both are standard, both are taught, and they disagree by two percentage points on the same company at the same moment. Neither is wrong: they are answering slightly different questions. CAPM asks what return the market demands for bearing this share's exposure to market risk. The dividend model asks what return the current price implies, given what the company actually pays out. When they diverge, the gap is information — it usually means the market price embeds a growth expectation different from the one you typed.

Advertentie

CAPM and the dividend growth model both compute the cost of equity. On one set of inputs they give 9 % and 7 % — and the choice between them decides a valuation more than any figure inside either.

Beta is a measurement, and a fragile one

Beta is estimated by regressing a share's returns on the market's, and the answer depends on choices nobody standardises: how far back the window goes, whether the returns are daily, weekly or monthly, and which index stands for the market. The same share can come out at 1.0 on one convention and 1.4 on another, which on the numbers above is a full two points of cost of equity. When a valuation turns on a beta, it is worth asking where the beta came from before arguing about anything else.

When the dividend model simply does not apply

It needs a dividend, and a growth rate below the cost of equity. A company paying nothing has a dividend yield of zero and the model collapses to the growth rate alone, which is meaningless. A company whose assumed growth exceeds its cost of equity produces a negative denominator elsewhere in the same family of formulas and an answer that is worse than meaningless. CAPM has neither constraint, which is most of why it survives in practice — not because it is more accurate, but because it always returns something.

The same company, both models
ModelBuilt fromCost of equity
CAPMrisk-free + beta × market premium9 %
Dividend growthdividend ÷ price + growth7 %

Uitgewerkt met onze eigen calculator

Calculator kosten eigen vermogen (CAPM en DDM)

Gegeven

Risicovrije rente (%)
4,5
Bèta (β)
1,15
Verwacht marktrendement (%)
10
Verwacht dividend D₁
€ 3,50
Huidige aandelenkoers P₀
€ 145,00
Dividendgroeivoet g (%)
5

Resultaat

Kosten eigen vermogen — CAPM
10,82%
Kosten eigen vermogen — DDM
7,41%

Deze cijfers komen uit de calculator hieronder, ze zijn niet met de hand ingetypt — ze worden opnieuw berekend telkens als de tool verandert.

Reken het door met je eigen cijfers →
Advertentie

Veelgestelde vragen

Which of the two should I use?
Use both and treat the gap as the answer's width. A single cost of equity presented to two decimal places is a false precision on a quantity nobody can observe; a range of 7 % to 9 % is an honest one. If a decision flips between those two figures, the decision was never really about the cost of equity.
What counts as the risk-free rate?
By convention, a long government bond yield in the currency of the cash flows, with a maturity close to the horizon being valued. The convention matters more than the theory: what makes a rate usable here is that everyone comparing your figure uses the same one. Mixing a euro risk-free rate with dollar cash flows is the common error, and it shifts the answer by whatever the interest-rate differential happens to be.

Artikelen die je misschien interesseren

Alle gidsen →
UitlegOne Point of Discount Rate Moves a Perpetuity by a QuarterA payment of 1,000 a year is worth 20,000 at a 5 % discount rate and 25,000 at 4 %. The formula is a single division, and that is exactly why the input matters more than the arithmetic.UitlegA Dividend Yield Rises When the Share Price Falls500 shares paying $2.40 each is $1,200 of income. At a $60 share price that is a 4% yield; if the price halves to $30 the yield doubles to 8% with no extra cash.UitlegThe Treynor Ratio Is Only as Solid as Its BetaEight points of excess return over a beta of 1.2 gives 6.67. Change the beta to 0.6 and the same portfolio scores 13.33 — the number moves entirely on an estimate.UitlegAveraging Down Halves the Loss and Doubles the PositionTen shares at 100 plus twenty at 80 gives an average of 86.67. Buy forty at 50 instead and it falls to 60 — but the money at risk goes from 2,600 to 3,000.UitlegThe Sortino Denominator Nobody Agrees OnOn one twelve-month series the Sortino ratio is 7.7518 or 3.8759 depending only on whether the squared shortfalls are divided by all twelve months or by the three below target. The two conventions differ by exactly the square root of twelve over three, and they can rank two funds in opposite orders.UitlegKoersrendement, totaalrendement en dividendrendement zijn drie verschillende getallenDe index die in het nieuws wordt genoemd, is bijna altijd een koersindex. Bij 5 procent koersgroei en een herbelegd rendement van 2,5 procent maken 30 jaar van € 10.000 € 43.219 op de koers en € 90.656 op het totaalrendement — de koersmaat mist 58,8 procent van de winst.

Vergelijkbare tools

Bronnen

Een fout in dit artikel gezien?