Skip to content
OneKitly

A Monthly Deposit Plan Earns Less Than Half the Headline Rate

Published 11/18/2026 · 3 min read · Finance calculators

Camille Laurent

Camille Laurent — Finance writer at OneKitly

Tax · Personal finance

Checked against 2 sources

View profile →
In short

In a recurring deposit each instalment earns interest only from the day it arrives, so the first payment works for the full term and the last one for a month. Paying $5,000 a month for five years at 7% compounded quarterly deposits $300,000 and matures at $359,664, an interest total of $59,664. That is 19.9% on the money paid in, while the same $300,000 placed as a lump sum at the start would have grown to $420,766 — a gain of 40%. Both are earning 7%; they are simply earning it for different lengths of time, and the average instalment has been invested for two and a half years rather than five.

Advertisement

$5,000 a month for five years at 7% pays $59,664 of interest on $300,000 deposited — 19.9%, not the 40% a lump sum would have earned over the same period.

Why the comparison is unfair anyway

Anybody choosing a monthly plan does not have the lump sum on day one, so the alternative was never available. The right comparison is against holding each instalment in a current account until the end, which earns nothing, and against that the plan is worth every cent of the $59,664. Judging a savings vehicle against a scenario the saver could not have chosen is the most common way to feel cheated by an entirely reasonable product.

Compounding frequency moves the answer less than the schedule does

Switching the same plan from quarterly to monthly compounding adds a few hundred to the maturity value, while changing the payment schedule moves it by tens of thousands. Savers tend to shop on the compounding line because it is printed prominently and comparable, and to ignore when the money actually goes in, which is the variable that dominates. Paying at the start of each month rather than the end is worth more than any realistic change in compounding.

Five years, $300,000, two ways of paying it in
MethodFinal valueGain
$5,000 a month$359,66419.9%
$300,000 at the start$420,76640.3%
Difference$61,102Time, not rate

Worked with our own calculator

RD calculator (recurring deposit)

Given

Monthly deposit
$2,500.00
Annual interest rate (%)
6.3
Compounding
Monthly
Tenure — years
3
Tenure — extra months
1

Result

Maturity amount
$102,335.85
Total deposited
$92,500.00
Interest earned
$9,835.85

These figures are produced by the calculator below, not typed in by hand — they are recomputed whenever the tool changes.

Run it on your own figures →
Advertisement

Frequently asked questions

What rate would a lump sum need to match this?
About 3.7% over the same five years, which is roughly half the headline rate. That figure is the honest way to compare a deposit plan with a one-off investment, and it is not usually printed anywhere. Working it out takes one line: find the rate that grows $300,000 to $359,664 in five years. Any product whose advertised rate applies to money that is not yet there deserves the same treatment before signing.
Does the same apply to a pension contribution?
Exactly, and over forty years the effect is enormous in the other direction. A contribution made at twenty-five compounds for four decades while one made at sixty compounds for five years, so the early payments dominate the final pot even though every payment is the same size. The standard illustration — two savers, one starting ten years earlier and stopping, still ahead at retirement — is this same arithmetic with the numbers chosen to be dramatic.

Articles you may find interesting

All guides →

Related tools

Sources

Spotted a mistake in this article?