The Margin Fell From 70 to 60 Per Cent Without Changing a Price
Published 11/6/2026 · 3 min read · Business tools
Fixed costs do not care how much you sell, so they eat a larger share of a smaller business. A stand selling 100 cups at $1.50 with $0.35 of ingredients each and $10 spent on the stand itself takes $150, keeps $105 and reports a 70 % margin. Sell only 40 cups and the revenue falls to $60, the profit to $36, and the margin to 60 % — the same price, the same recipe, ten points of margin gone. Raise the fixed cost to $40 while keeping 100 cups and the margin lands at 50 %. The break-even point is nine cups in the first case and thirty-five in the third.
100 cups at $1.50 with $0.35 of ingredients and $10 of fixed costs yields 70 %. Sell 40 cups instead and the same prices yield 60 %.
Two margins, and only one of them is a property of the product
The contribution margin — price minus the cost of one more unit, here $1.15 out of $1.50, or 76.7 % — belongs to the recipe and does not move with volume. The overall margin reported by the calculator divides profit by revenue after fixed costs, and it climbs with every additional cup sold because the fixed cost is being spread thinner. Quoting the second without the first makes a business look as though it improves with scale by magic; quoting the first alone makes it look profitable before it has paid for the table. Both are needed, and the difference between them is exactly the fixed cost per unit sold.
Raising the price beats selling more, usually
Going from $1.50 to $2.00 on the same hundred cups lifts profit from $105 to $155 — half as much again, from a change that costs nothing to implement. Selling fifty per cent more cups at the old price would have lifted profit to $162.50, close to the same, while requiring half as much again of everything: ingredients, time, standing there. Price is the only lever that improves the result without also increasing the work, which is why it is the first place to look and the last place most small operations touch. The risk is entirely on the demand side, and the way to find out is to try it for an afternoon.
| Setup | Profit | Margin and break-even |
|---|---|---|
| 100 cups, $10 fixed | $105 | 70 %, 9 cups |
| 40 cups, $10 fixed | $36 | 60 %, 9 cups |
| 100 cups, $40 fixed | $75 | 50 %, 35 cups |
| 100 cups at $2.00, $10 fixed | $155 | 77.5 %, 7 cups |
Worked with our own calculator
Lemonade stand profit calculator
Given
- Cups sold
- 200
- Price per cup
- $3.00
- Ingredient cost per cup
- $0.70
- Fixed costs (stand, sign…)
- $20.00
Result
- Revenue
- $600.00
- Profit
- $440.00
- Profit margin
- 73.33%
- Break-even (cups)
- 9
These figures are produced by the calculator below, not typed in by hand — they are recomputed whenever the tool changes.
Run it on your own figures →Frequently asked questions
- Why is the break-even the same at 40 and 100 cups?
- Because the break-even depends only on the fixed cost and the profit per cup, not on how many you eventually sell. Nine cups at $1.15 of contribution each covers the $10 spent on the stand, and everything after that is profit whether the day ends at forty cups or a hundred. That is why the figure is useful before opening rather than after: it says how much of the day has to go right before the venture stops losing money, and it can be computed the moment the two costs are known.
- Should unsold ingredients count as a loss?
- Only the ones that spoil. Lemons that keep for another week are inventory rather than expense, and counting them as a cost of today's trading understates today's profit and overstates tomorrow's. Cut fruit, made-up syrup and anything already mixed are a different matter: those were consumed by the decision to prepare them and belong to the day they were made. The distinction matters most for anyone deciding how much to prepare, since over-preparing a perishable is a real cost and over-buying a keeping one is only a cash-flow question.
Articles you may find interesting
All guides →Related tools
Sources
Spotted a mistake in this article?